Cincinnati had $874,530,548.30 worth of Emergencies this week.

Yesterday’s Budget & Finance Committee apparently had so many last-minute, unforeseeable emergencies pop-up out of nowhere that City Administration didn’t have time to post an agenda before they went home on Friday.  When the public did finally get a peek at the ordinances on Monday the value of those emergencies totaled $874,530,548.30.

Money figures we read in newspapers these days have gotten so big they have lost any real meaning for normal people who lead normal lives,  you know, people who get up every day, go to work, try to figure out where to find the money to pay their $1,800 property tax bill.  So let’s focus.


Not quite 15% short of a billion dollars.

One week.

I’m going to say that again.  These are the Emergencies for one week.

Do you get it now?

Under Ohio law and the city of Cincinnati’s charter, an ordinance must have three readings before council votes on it, which means a standard ordinance would take an average of three weeks to work through the city’s legislative process.

According to a superb article by Lucy May in the Business Courier on October 28, 2011,” council often votes to waive those three readings, which it can do if a super-majority of three-fourths of the council votes in favor of that. Then it takes a two-thirds majority of council to consider an ordinance an emergency. By reducing the number of weeks a measure is considered, and eliminating the chance for a referendum, council effectively limits the voice of the citizens, Curp said. It’s not that the city breaks the law, he said. Council passes the laws legitimately, and the city requires the super-majorities.”  (John Curp was the city’s former chief solicitor, widely respected by everybody who worked with him.)

She also quotes a really smart lawyer I know, Peter Koenig, a partner with Buechner Haffer Meyers & Koenig, as saying, “Not everything called an emergency is an emergency.  It’s that simple. It’s preposterous for city council to be labeling every piece of important legislation an emergency. They’re afraid of the light of day. And it’s their way of hiding what they’re really doing.”

Now let’s look at what City Administration decided the public was allowed to talk about and what they decided was none of our business (or maybe that we aren’t smart enough to have anything of importance to add to the conversation).

Regular Ordinances this week included: application for a Police Justice Assistance Grant and Police Body-word Camera Pilot Implementation Program Grant, application for Police & Fire Joint FEMA Port Security Grant, Customer Service feasibility study, summer youth employment program appropriation, the sale of Harry Alley in Clifton, application for a Local Government Innovation Fund Grant, Municipal Road Fund Agreements of $450,000 – and – a 12-year CRA (Community Reinvestment Act) abatement and Job Creation Tax Credit on a modest $1,000,000 warehouse economic development in Spring Grove Village.

So the public was allowed to talk about taxpayer-supported projects valued at $1,450,000.  And we weren’t allowed to talk about taxpayer-supported projects of $874,530,548.30.

Efficiency is a great goal.  We’d never get anything done if we publicly debated every single vote that comes before City Council.  But when Citizens are deliberately excluded from the public conversation on a dollar ratio of 800 to 1, we have opened ourselves as a community to disproportional influence by those who can afford to pay for it: for-profit corporations, developers and lobbyists. And that, dear friends, is the real emergency in Cincinnati.

9 thoughts on “Cincinnati had $874,530,548.30 worth of Emergencies this week.

  1. Craig Hochscheid

    Back in the halcyon days of the mayoral election John Cranley criticized the use of emergency ordinances and promised that his administration would see a new era of transparency where EO’s would only be used in cases of true emergencies. So much for that campaign promise.

    1. Quimbob

      HAH – gotta love the lying little bug.
      That being said, the vast majority of ‘legislations’ don’t need the scrutiny but it does add up and is easily abused.
      I thought there was a $ cap on what could be passed as an emergency, tho.

  2. executivedreamer Post author

    My guess, Mr. Quimbob, human nature being what it is – all legislatures will always need scrutiny. That’s why we have public records. And this practice did not start with current administration. It’s been standard operating procedure for 30 years – but the dollar signs are growing exponentially with the passage of time – and it’s got me scared. There has never been a cap on what the public doesn’t need to know.

    1. executivedreamer Post author

      Oh – and in all fairness – I should admit that this agenda and these emergencies include some biggies that don’t come around very often: sewers, refinancing some streetcar debt (that’s only 40 million), Harry Black’s new CAP initiative to speed up street improvements and fleet replacement (I’d kind of like to talk about that one a little more). There’s a new TIF project for the old SCPA building that’s going to be turned into apartments. You know – a million here, a hundred million there and it all adds up.

  3. executivedreamer Post author

    I got out my calculator and added up every entry from the 394 page (give or take a few pages – please pardon my not going back to look it up again right now) agenda posted online under Council agendas. It takes a long time to go through the full document – but you learn a lot along the way. Including the part about no new jobs from the Anthem development. That’s written right in the ordinance.

    1. executivedreamer Post author

      I did have a lovely local rabbit dish for lunch today, followed by a walk along the beach. The sky was bright blue. Michele and I are on the same continent (he got here a few days after I did)- pinching ourselves all the time, to make sure one of us isn’t in a dream. — But I can’t help it, Paul, I have this idea about Cincinnati in my head,, the kind of Cincinnati where I’ve always wanted to live, imaginative and fun and nice people working together to make something unique of ourselves. One that’s a little messy around the edges. With simple values that can’t be put on spreadsheets. It’s so real to me, I can’t stop playing Girl Detective. I really believe we can get to the city in my head. But I should probably go for a swim in the sea tomorrow, shouldn’t I?


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s